Capitalmind
Capitalmind
Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial
Commentary

NSEL Update: Audit Shows Less Than 20% of Stock, Untraceable Borrowers, Related Parties, Where is the CBI?

The crisis behind the NSEL (National Spot Exchange) is getting more and more murky.

The Exchange released client positions behind the 24 members who “owe” the exchange 5600 cr. rupees. These clients are the actual companies that have done one leg (selling goods in the T+2 contract) and who have defaulted on the reverse leg (buy goods back in the longer term (like T+36) contracts).

Now, Sundaresha Subramanian (who is a rock star when it comes to NSEL revealing journalism) has found that one “client” of Mohan India (a member), Mangla Shree Properties, which owes Rs. 720 cr. to NSEL, has an address which is now a multi-storyed mall.

Further, Mohan India’s director, Jagmohan, owns 1.33 lakh shares in Mangla Shree Properties, which Mangla Shree’s promoter Anil Mangla has categorically refuted earlier.

And the, the audit by Swiss SGS shows that warehouses of NSEL have less than 1/5th the stock they are supposed to have. And to increase the suspicion that this was a fraud on a massive scale, SGS was refused entry into some warehouses which are within the premises of the borrowers.

How incompetent was NSEL to let a counterparty actually control the goods and warehouses? Since the counterparty is not known to a buyer, it was NSEL’s responsibility to have kept goods in their own warehouses, or employed techniques to provide adequate inventory.

Or, was it completely aware of the goings on?

Where is the CBI?

If we have to tell, we need a CBI investigation, at the very least. People demand CBI investigations routinely, even if a certain Ms. Gandhi’s puppy were to lose a toenail ahead of time. Yet, nothing when it comes to the vanishing of Rs. 5,600 cr.?

And There’s Not 24 Parties – Some Are Related

There are many related parties in the list of companies. One “member”, Juggernaut Projects which owes Rs. 220 cr., has a director named “Bethamcherla Venkata Hari Prasad”.

Mr. Prasad is also a director of BSPN Exports (named as a client of Spin Cot Textiles, a DIFFERENT member) owing Rs. 40 cr.

Mr. Prasad is also a director of VBG Infrastructure, who is a client of both Juggernaut and another member, Aastha Minmet.

We already know that the Exchange’s ex-chairman, Shankarlal Guru is the father-in-law of one of the defaulters (NK Proteins)

ET has more details on who’s-who.

This is a story of lies and deceit that is now brazen. And still, we haven’t seen a single arrest.

  • Deepak the shocking thing is not a word in parliament which is in session right now.
    Normally opposition benches would raise a hue and cry even if a certain Ms. Gandhi’s puppy would as much as bark at a certain Mr. Modi’s puppy cat. But where is the opposition voice on this 6000 cr scam. Not a word.
    Probably the oppn is more used to 1 Lakhs cr plus scams and a four figure scam is not worth yelling about.
    Aasaram should be arrested according to the media. But the prime accused in the coal scam will not be arrested who happens to be a certain Mr. Singh. Mr. Jignesh Shah will not be arrested….WHY IS THE MEDIA SILENT?????