Capitalmind
Capitalmind
Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial
Charts & Analysis

VIX Not Indicating Panic Even As Market Slides 3%

While broad markets fell 3% today, the biggest intra-day move in more than a year, it seems the Volatility Index (VIX) based on option premiums wasn’t hitting any peaks.

image

With a figure of 19.19, the VIX is way lower than the heights of 35+ that it saw in 2011 (when, btw, the rupee was sliding just as much and markets were falling).

What this means is: the VIX is not really an indicator of volatility anymore. Options have become a massive part of the market nowadays, especially on the Nifty. This can substantially skew calculations. For instance, the market puts the 5700 put on the Nifty at just Rs. 92.65, when the Nifty’s at 5655 (and the future is even lower, at 5640). Effectively that option is in the money if the Nifty falls 40 points in one week (expiry is next Thursday) and the Nifty just fell 150 points in a single day!

When options are so mispriced it is very useful to buy them. I have a December 2013 5500 put that I bought at Rs. 120, and which is now at Rs. 185, and even that sounds cheap! (a 6% further downmove would take it to in the money – and even less to make the option more valuable, which is what you really want)

However less useful the VIX as a number is, the trend of its move and a comparison to its own historical past tells you if people expect the market to be volatile. We’re coloured by recent experiences of “bouncebacks” and directionless-ness, which might explain the lack of panic. If it comes when we least expect it, we’re least expecting it now.

Destiny will meet us on the road we take to avoid it.

  • Anil says:

    Good one Deepak…
    Even I bought 5500 Dec-13 put at 90, simply as a way of insurance against steep fall in market. I thought annualised premium of around 3% is cheap enough, though your logic explains me clearly why it was trading cheap and will be useful to me in future….

  • K.S.Saravanan says:

    Good Analysis Deepak

  • Adithya says:

    Curious how the VIX line looks when u plot the implied for out of the money options. should be way more “crisis” sensitive but also noisy

  • ananth says:

    Love the Quote “Destiny will meet us on the road we take to avoid it”. So true!

  • Murty says:

    VIX is not panicking!
    Even the FM says Rupee depreciation is not a worry.
    I can not draw the parlance between FM and Deepak Shenoy and say Deepak is FM Stuff!
    But now I doubt, like FM Deepak is just writing stuff and had a sound Debt portfolio, as declared by our beloved FM:):):):):)

  • Prashanth says:

    Deepak,
    Why do you say December put at Rs 185 is cheap? Meaning, what would its ‘fair’ value be?