Capitalmind
Capitalmind
Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial
Economy

India *HAS* Seen Negative GDP Growth, BoP Confirms Data Fudge

In an earlier post (Has India Plunged Into Recession? GDP Data Fudge Reveals Details) I spoke of how the import-export data was likely to be heavily wrong. The RBI has released the Balance of Payments data for Jan-Mar 2012 and it turns out that indeed, I was right.

The GDP figures (released by CSO, which comes under MOSPI, a government ministry) showed this for Q4 2011-12:

image

First, the total imports and exports figure was wrong.

For Q4 2012 GDP Data
(Rs. Cr.)
RBI BoP data
(Rs. Cr.)
Difference
Exports 679,926 591,790   -13%
Imports 631,398 762,716   +21%

Note: All data is at “current prices” (that is, not adjusted for inflation)

Essentially, exports were overstated by 13% and imports were understated by 21%. That’s a huge difference, and will take the GDP growth into negative territory.

Much of that, I had decoded was because “service exports and imports” were the missing component (we only knew about goods exports and imports, through the commerce ministroy).

For Q4 2012 My estimates(Rs. Cr.) RBI BoP data
(Rs. Cr.)
Difference
Exports 605,117 591,790   -2%
Imports 738,982 762,716   +3.2%

Even I was wrong, it seems, having understated the deficit by about 5%. The net export is about (-170,926 cr.), negative because we’ve imported more than exports. The GDP data had said we exported 48,000 cr. more than our imports in Q4 FY12.

If you add this all in, the GDP falls by about 220,000 cr. The March 2012 quarter GDP falls to 22.29 trillion, which is a nominal growth of just 2.2% over Q4 2011 (Jan to Mar 2011).

Since real growth will subtract inflation, which is running at 7%, we should have seen negative growth (or, in better english, a contraction in real GDP) in the last quarter of 2011-12. Of course, you need two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth to qualify for a recession but we haven’t seen such a bleed in a long long time.

  • Krishna says:

    HI Deepak,
    You are doing great analysis on the data. It is quite useful and reveals the real facts. Before reading your post, I have read the same fact in one another regional magazine about the wrong interpretation of the GDP data. your article clears my doubt with data. what would happen to India’s growth?
    I could see many of the companies in India biggest problem but our govt. not taken anything seriously. One example is the price manipulation in the cement industry.
    Thanks,
    Krishna

  • fubar says:

    Amazing that no one gets fired for dishing out such horribly wrong data.

  • Kshitij says:

    For non -economists, will it be possible for you to explain the nos adjusted for inflation and in dollar terms. Do the nos look far worse?

  • DJ Waghmare says:

    Have you done this exercise for earlier quarters? If there is such a serious under-statement of growth, I wonder if at all India had that 9-10% growth in earlier years. Thanks for this post, very educative as all your posts normally are. Keep up the good work sir, would like some personal finance posts although I can make out that you are a very busy man too.

  • Krishna says:

    Why they have to manipulate the data?

  • hp says:

    It will be great if you had a chart that showed the delta between BoP and GDP data for earlier quarters and comparing it to the current quarter. Lets see if the delta is significantly different this time around.