- Wealth PMS
I write about how short term Debt Mutual Funds have done way better than fixed deposits and are tax efficient as well, in “Reconsider that Fixed Deposit”
“Inflation rears its ugly head again, as RBI prepares to raise interest rates.” You hear this all the time, and then wonder why you should bother. Over a year now, we, the retail public have been getting horrendously low deposit rates from banks. And if we got a bank offering us 9% deposit rates, the interest was taxed; and at the highest bracket, our real return was only 6.3%.
But this sounds incongruous with what the papers are telling us — that liquidity is tight, or that banks want money. If they are, why aren’t we getting better deposit rates?
I have an emergency fund — 6 to 12 months of expenses — in a safe avenue, but I don’t know if this emergency will happen in 1 month or after 5 years. My putting the money in a fixed deposit yields very little; plus, I end up paying tax on the interest. And if I use a longer term deposit, I get hit by a pre-closure penalty if I should have an emergency in the meantime.
So we’ve got three issues — we don’t get the best interest rates, we pay taxes on the interest even if we reinvest it, and we fear pre-closure penalties. Is there a way around this, retaining the same safety as a fixed deposit?
Enter the debt mutual fund. Mutual funds are assumed to have equity exposure, but that is a fallacy; in India, more than 80% of mutual fund assets are in non-equity investments, mostly fixed income products. These invest in markets where money is traded, like call money markets, fixed income derivatives, bond markets; here, what you would get for a 1-year investment with the same bank is likely to be higher than what the bank offers for retail deposits.
For example, on Tuesday (18 Jan), an HDFC bank “Certificate of Deposit” (CD) was available at an interest of 9.74% for one year (You can see what was traded at http://www.fimmda.org) The best HDFC Bank Deposit for a one year term is 8.25% – so the difference is substantial. You and I can’t participate directly in these markets — plus, ticket sizes are 1 crore or more. The way to get in is to invest through a debt mutual fund; in this case, “ultra short term” or “floating rate” funds. They buy these CDs, charge a management fee of the order of 0.5%, and give you the rest.
When rates go up, these funds rotate money often, investing in short term instruments (sometimes as short as one day), and take advantage of the rate increases as they happen.
But then, you ask, what about taxes? In mutual funds, you don’t get taxed on any intermediate gains until you decide to sell. Keep the money in for two years? The fund may rack up gains, you don’t pay tax. And if you decide to sell after a year, you get the additional benefit of long term capital gains tax, which I’ll illustrate with an example.
Let’s say you put in 500,000 into such a fund, exit after a year, and get a 9% return. That’s Rs. 45,000 of gains. With long term capital gains, you get to “index” the gains; that means, they let you adjust the principal up for inflation. The 500,000 that you invested will be considered as 530,000 (assuming 6% is the announced inflation). Your taxable gain is only 15,000 — and the tax on that is, at 20% currently, just Rs. 3,000.
Compare that with making 45,000 in a fixed deposit — it will be added to your income and taxed; at the highest tax slab, you pay 30% of it, or Rs. 13,500 in taxes.
Now, consider the real world. It’s hardly likely you would need the entire 500,000 you have stored for a rainy day. You might need Rs. 50,000 for an operation, or Rs. 100,000 to cover an emergency, but not the full amount. With a mutual fund, you can draw only a little bit at a time, without a penalty — and while certain fixed deposits do allow you early partial exits through a “sweep-in” facility, but most banks have started to charge a penalty for early exits.
Finally, funds are just as flexible. Nowadays you can buy and sell online, through the fund’s website, your bank or your brokerage account. Money gets directly credited into your account, so it’s just as hassle-free as a fixed deposit.
And of course, there are negatives. Today, we have a rising interest rate situation. When rates start to come down, floating rate funds are not the place to be.
We have a “flat” yield curve; at the shorter end (1 year or less to maturity) interest rates are very high — from 7.4% to 10%, with even 20 year debt sticking in the 8.5% to 10% ranges. If the curve “steepens”, or short term debt becomes substantially cheaper compared to the longer term, then these floating rate products will likely give lower returns. But with RBI looking to hike up rates (RBI can only change short term rates at the moment) it’s unlikely we see a steepening event that will hurt us — at least, in the one year term that people usually consider for fixed deposits.
Additionally, the risk in mutual funds is that they can choose to invest where they want; what if they buy dodgy instruments? These funds reveal their portfolio monthly, but you’ll still need to check and see if they are buying rotten apples.
And the last risk is that rates aren’t guaranteed, like you see with fixed deposits. They move according to the market prices. We love our sticker prices, and we love our guaranteed rates. But the risks seem benign; it’s time to look at products that don’t keep adding to our tax bill unnecessarily, and give us both flexibility and competitive returns.
More Yahoo Columns:
To subscribe to new posts by email, once a day, delivered to your Inbox:
Also, do check out Capital Mind Premium , where we provide high
quality analysis on macro, fixed income and stocks. Also see our
portfolio which has given stellar returns in our year, trade by trade
as we progress. Take a 30-day trial: