Capitalmind
Capitalmind
Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial
Personal Finance

Capital Protection Funds: Worth it?

There are a number of New Fund Offers out there, for Capital Protection Funds, which means you invest some money today and they kinda-sorta guarantee that you will get at least the amount you invest. Typical fund structure, let’s look at the Sundaram Capital Protection Oriented Fund, Series 2:

Type: Closed Ended, means if you buy now you can’t buy more of this later, and you have to stay on for the full term.

Term: Three years.

Concept: 80%-100% debt, rest equity or fixed-income derivatives.

Liquidity: They won’t let you exit early by selling back to them, but will list on stock exchanges.

So how do they do it?

Guarantee capital, that is.

Simple. You can’t get out before three years. If they invest in a three year “safe” instrument, like government securities, they are safe. But how much do they invest?

Let’s see the current 3 year government bond – the yield is around 7.13%, but let’s just say 7%. Then deduct fund management fees of about 2.25% per year. They only need to invest Rs. 87 for every Rs. 100 they get at the NFO, so that the capital is protected – i.e. after three years, their Rs. 87 will grow to Rs. 100.

The remaining Rs. 13, they can invest in equity, in fixed-income derivatives (Interest Rate Swaps, FRAs) or other such instruments. This provides a “kicker” – even if they lose it all, your capital is protected.

What’s the problem?

The 2.25% per year as fees. You are paying 6.75% to a fund that doesn’t need to do much – in fact, with the 87-13 structure, it is possible to construct a portfolio that both secures capital and gives you about 1x Nifty returns (i.e. if the Nifty returned 10% in the three years, the product will return 10%, but on the downside it loses nothing). This is simply through a "Structured Product” concept I’d spoken about earlier – and without the 2.25% a year as “fees”, you can earn substantially higher returns.

And the liquidity?

Is a joke. Of the few cap protected funds that are listed (search this list for “cap” and check quotes) I couldn’t find any that actually traded. So assume you’ll be in for three years.

Conclusion: I don’t think this kind of fund or product is worth investing in. Simply buy short term funds for capital security with 80% of the money, and put the rest in something you can take risk on – like an index fund. Or, invest in a Monthly Income Plan (MIP) that offers similar structures. They may not guarantee returns but will take less than 2.25% every year (Good MIPs take 1.5%) and allow you to enter and exit at anytime. Sure, most MIPs come with an exit load if you leave within a year, but these cap protection funds lock your money for three years.

I don’t like to write posts that say “don’t bother”; but I have been getting too many of these “Invest in a Capital Protection NFO” emails lately and reader questions about them, so I needed to clarify my thoughts.

  • abhikush says:

    >Deepak, I had actually posted this question in the Structured Product post as well.

    I do not understand the product. Let me know if the following are the correct pay-offs:
    Index <= 5000: Only Principal is returned
    5000 < Index < 6250: Principal + Index Returns + 10% of Index Returns
    Index >= 6250: Principal + 10.75% returned

    I do not understand how they can make profit when Index is between 5000 & 6250 for the duration of the product. Or do I have the pay-offs for second scenario wrong?

  • Deepak Shenoy says:

    >abhikush – the quantity of options = 1.1x the exposure. So for 5 lakh rupees you buy call options that expose you to 5.5 lakh of Nifty. That's how the 1.1 payoff comes.

  • Anonymous says:

    >Last week SEBI has warned investors that quality of Debt papers in such long term closed ended Schemes are suspect. As you know the Alphabet Soups (structured Obligations, Pass Thro Certificates etc.) are nothing but Securitised Debt of Banks/NBFCs which have lent to Micro Finance, Real Estate Companies, Auto Loans etc.
    Sundaram MF have very poor record of managing Debt Fund.
    The main reason for such hype is Broker's Commission.
    Beware-Beware.
    MK

  • Anonymous says:

    >Dear Deepak,
    Is there any fund in the market which invests 80% in Debt and 20% in Futures and Options exclusively. I could not find one so far. Is there any SEBI ban in offering such a Fund?
    MK

  • Anonymous says:

    >Reading your earlier post on structured products as well as this one . . . am just wondering if there is enough liquidity in long dated options traded on NSE. is that what they use? or is there an OTC market for this which institutions have access to?

    how do you imagine this can be replicated as a homebrew . . . possible with existing traded instruments?

    R.T.

  • Deepak Shenoy says:

    >MK: don't know of any, unfortuantely. They are allowed, just that they can't end up being net short.

    RT: This is liquidity, but it comes in spurts so you have to time it right…