Capitalmind
Capitalmind
Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial
Commentary

Nifty Pre-Open Auction from 9:00 to 9:15

On the NSE, there will be a pre-open auction session from 9:00 to 9:15 after which regular trading will happen.

Why a pre-open auction?

The “open” price has been very unreliable, basically because it’s the first price traded. Many brokers allow their clients to place orders overnight and release those orders into the exchange the first thing in the morning. This can cause serious imbalances because many customers, sometimes from lack of knowledge and other times from misinformation from the brokers, place “At Market” orders before the open, which means the orders will be executed at whatever price there is someone on the other side. Obviously this can be used to manipulate the price – a counter for a “market order” can be a proprietary arm of the broker, who knows about the market orders, placing crazy limit orders on the other side. Look at my post on Ranbaxy spiking to 660 at the open in 2008.

A lot of pre-open orders are also placed based on overnight news – any news after 3:30 pm can only be accomodated in the stock the next morning, but people tend to panic and place market sell or buy orders with their brokers.

So what happens?

  • From 9:00 to 9:08, limit or market orders will be allowed. But they won’t be executed.
  • Post 9:08, there will be a matching session.
  • In this, the “equilibrium” Open price will be calculated first. Based on the limit orders, the price at which the maximum volume can be executed is used as the Open price. If you have 100 orders for a total quantity of 100,000 shares between Rs. 500 and Rs. 510, but the price at which highest volume can immediately be executed is say Rs. 507 for 75,000 shares (the rest are either buy orders below 507 or sell orders above 507) then 507 is the equilibrium Open price.
  • In the matching session no more orders are allowed. All limit buy orders above 507 get matched to all sell orders below 507, at the equilibrium 507 price. If say there are a few more limit buys remaining, they get matched with “At Market” sell orders, and then all Market Sell orders get matched with all Market Buy orders, all at the price of 507. While that was an example, this happens will all securities at the equilibrium price. (Only “Eligible” securities)
  • The remaining orders are then placed into the order queues for regular trading.

If there is no price discovery possible because of lack of orders, there is no matching and the regular trading happens at 9:15.

“Eligible” Securities?

In their infinite wisdom, the NSE has decided that this should apply only to Sensex and Nifty stocks. This is unfortunate, because open price manipulation happens largely in second rung stocks. The rest of the stocks won’t trade at all till 9:15.

Derivative markets will only open at 9:15.

How does it affect traders?

Because of the massive volume at the start, day traders would work into the 9AM start. Some of that volatility will be tempered by the open auction. For derivatives traders this just means a later start. For arbitrageurs it’s a better mechanism to work the day, but they do miss out on on opportunities created by the open. This is not great for prop-shops or prop-arms of large brokerages, but then this was waiting to happen anyhow.

What’s also interesting is that open-circuits are unlikely to happen with adverse trades. That is, if the open causes a exchange-wide circuit, it will happen before regular trading. Remember, we have had opening-circuit hits three times in the last three years – down in 2007 October (On SEBI banning p-notes), lower circuit in 2008 Jan (on the meltdown), upper circuit in 2009 (great election results).

To me, not much of a difference – I don’t trade before 9:30 AM anyhow.

  • ayondutta says:

    >I use freewares to obtain daily OHLC data from the NSE site. Any idea whether this pre-open auction will provide "cleaner" data? Does this make for better candlestick patterns for a technical analyst?

  • Anonymous says:

    >Few things you need to know, the exchanges have precious little to do these days with the entire laundry list of what to do and what not being prescribed by the Regulator.. Its SEBI's notification which limits the number of stocks to 50 and not the exchanges "Infinite Wisdom"

    For a change BSE (yes there is an exchange by that name in India) has a wonderful section on the entire call auction process, here is the link
    http://www.bseindia.com/callauction/introduction.aspx

    In addition to the academic details, there is simplified brochure and even a video to help people understand the process. And there are brochures in 5 Indian Languages to help the people understand the entire process.. Do have a look there…

  • Yashodhan says:

    >Thanks….very informative article

  • Ananth says:

    Hi Deepak,
    If orders won’t be executed till 9:08, what does the quotes we see on T.V in that period mean.

  • manish says:

    Prices Between 9 to 9:15 – Its a notional price as if orders were executed then what will be the price. As per my views.

  • Imran Nadaf says:

    Hello,
    Can i book my Shares for tommorows Intraday.. ?
    on online not through Broker…
    Thanks,
    Imran