Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial

Mahindra Holidays EPS drops 63%

Club Mahindra (Mahindra Holidays) announced results on the 26th and the stock’s been seeing bad days. They highlight an occupancy ratio of 85%, but unfortunately the numbers seem to indicate that they are losing revenue at an alarming rate.

Usually for the hotel business, with a high occupancy rate, their revenues should have gone up. And that also means higher margins because you can charge higher fees to customers and walk-ins. But that’s not how it works for a timeshare – since customers pay upfront, a high occupancy rate is bad for profits, since it means you have to actually hire the staff and service the customers (whereas when you have a low occupancy rate, that bit goes into your pocket as profit).

Look at the numbers:




Revenues are down, expenses remain the same, and profits are way down. EPS is down 63%. They a trailing 12 month EPS of 12 and a market price of 491, which don’t quite make sense – which is probably why the stock has lost about 20% in the last three days.


(Click to enlarge)

Technically there should be a support level around 450, where the 200 DMA is, and further at the 400 levels. MACD and RSI are clearly negative in the short term. You could expect a dead cat bounce soon because of fading volumes on the downside, but there has not been much strength into the recent rise in the stock.

Also, that they are “overbooked” with respect to number of members and number of available rooms. Even if they took no walk-ins (remember, they do, you can book as a non-member too) they will leave about 30% of their members unsatisfied – and that percentage has not changed much in the last year.


Read my other posts on MHRIL – on their December 2009 results and my analysis of their IPO.

Hindustan Times, from IANS:

An company official told IANS on the condition of anonymity that the company has scrapped the 60 month equated monthly instalment scheme for enrolment membership.

He said the number of members enrolled during the first quarter of the current year is 1,494 lesser than what was enrolled during the corresponding period of the previous year thereby impacting the top line.

“During the quarter, the management initiated a number of measures to strengthen its acquisition process and took various steps to enhance customer satisfaction. These initiatives while impacting the numbers in the short run will benefit the company in improving productivity,” Chairman Arun Nanda said.

On the reduction in sales and marketing expenses, he said the focus is now on getting prospective client lead than other advertisement spend.

And from India Infoline:

Total income from operation for the quarter ended June 2010 declined by 25% to Rs 101.78 crore. The decline in the sales is due to stringent measures taken by the company. MHRIL has increased down payment from customers to 15% from 10% earlier. Maximum number of installment also decreased to 40 months from 60 months earlier. This stringent measure will decrease the number of cancellation. Operating profit margins crashed by 2090 bps to 22.6% due to increase in the costs and lesser revenues. Finally net profit fell by 61% to Rs 13.29 crore.

[…]In peak seasons, MHRIL stopped renting rooms for non-members. Also planning to stop renting rooms for non-members in non peak seasons too.

[…] Expects to add 400-500 rooms in FY’11.

Disclosure: No ownership. And I won’t be buying anytime soon. This is an “ok” stock with a very expensive price-tag.

  • Dhruva says:

    >just for record, I hate this timesharing model thing.

  • saurabh says:

    >Mahindra's took a long time to built their trust,but with this Holiday venture they are killing all that,after experiencing their hospitality many people are almost in a mental condition where they may need hospitalization.

    Last February 2010 i took their membership and was promised what not,LCD tv this n that,although my main concern was to get a nice holiday week every year,as soon as i got the membership i tried some bookings,In Feb they were telling me that no vacancy is there till July!!!!!Then and there i decided to cancel it(some 15 days cooling period was there) after lots of hassle emails,phone calls follow up i finally got back my money after full 5 months!!!!.

    They are corporate chors..errr….fraudsters.

    Government knows what is going on still they prey on innocence of people.


  • Anonymous says:

    >At last you have been proven right about this one.

    I was ready to start a lecture just like i did in HDFC about markets are supreme and stuff

  • Deepak Shenoy says:

    >Haha 🙂 Not yet proven right. Few more price points to go…