Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial

ICICI double lends against same properties after selling loans to ARCIL [Updated: News Denied]

Updated: ICICI prints a retraction, and ICAI says it denies such allegations.

ICICI double lends against same properties after selling loans to ARCIL [Updated: News Denied]

ICAI Denial:

ICICI double lends against same properties after selling loans to ARCIL [Updated: News Denied]

(Click for larger images)

Funny, ICICI says “The article is grossly inaccurate. The article mentions sale of home loans of Rs. 10,000 crores to ARCIL. The fact is that aggregate sale of home loans by the Bank to ARCIL since inception is less than Rs. 1,500 crores.”

That’s strange – Arcil (co sponsored by ICICI) bought more than 11,000 cr. of loans from ICICI as of March 2008 (LiveMint). The figure will be more now? Only 1500 of that is home loans? And if ICICI screwed up on some home loans it can’t screw up on the other regular loans?

(Original post follows)

ET: ICICI’s 10,000 cr. loan sale to Arcil under ICAI lens: (HT Anon reader)

The regulator should re-audit assets sold to ARCIL,” ICAI president Uttam Prakash Agarwal told SundayET, referring to the sale of bad home loan assets worth over Rs 10,000 crore by the bank to the asset reconstruction company.

ICICI Bank is accused of lending money for the purchase of some apartments in a housing project in a Mumbai suburb, and in some cases twice for the same set of apartments.

According to the chartered accountant who spotted irregularities, the bank disbursed home loans for the purchase of 15 apartments in the Ritu Paradise Project developed by S R Developers in Mumbai’s Mira Road. Documents available with ICAI and in SundayET’s possession show that double loans were issued by the Bank on some flats.

These loans were part of the block of bad loans sold to ARCIL, which helps banks to free up capital by buying such loans and seeks to recover them.

Although the loan amount for these 15 flats were only in the region of only Rs 2-3 crore, the accounting regulator is of the view that the bank bears responsibility for selling off these bad loans to ARCIL without verifying it.

A spokesman for ICICI Bank admitted that such an incident had taken place. “When this asset was sold to ARCIL, this was not identified as fraud. The builder fraudulently recreated the entire documentation and sought finance. Such frauds are a challenge to the industry,” he said. On the issue of loans being issued twice for the same property, the ICICI spokesman said: “Since there is no central database, it is almost impossible to track whether any loan has already been given against a specific property.”

But ICAI said this episode exposed holes in the bank’s systems. “In four cases, double loans were issued by ICICI Bank itself. This shows the inability of the bank’s IT set up and its due diligence mechanism,” Mr Agarwal said.

The time sequence seems to be: ICICI sold loans to Arcil. Later, it turned out the bank has issued mortgages again – different loans this time – against the same properties. Two loans issued by the bank against the same property is difficult to understand.

Did the bank officials know that Arcil now owned the loans, and thought they could get away with a second mortgage disbursal on the same property? Then it’s fraud. If not it’s a gross oversight, and ICAI is right in that ICICI should take the hit.

What this does is brings the entire 10,000 cr. into doubt; so all loans sold to Arcil will be under a scanner. Not just to verify against the underlying properties; they will need to check against all ICICI bank’s current other loans as well. Future sales of loans to Arcil will be hit; from now on the due diligence will be tighter and more clauses introduced. And will that hit growth? When you can’t get rid of bad loans, they sit and rot your balance sheet until they are written off, keeping NPAs high till then.

Funny, I got rid of this in the SoS due to a stop loss. But will the fundamental story hurt the stock price? Let’s see.

  • kudva says:

    >They have come up with a front page advertisement contesting this 😀

  • Deepak Shenoy says:

    >Roshan: A fundamental investor would never even bother about this stock – they have an EPS growth of close to zero for the last three years! Last quarter also, all the money was in trading, which is not sustainable; the banking arms (credit, fees) actually slowed down. No, the fundamentals of this company have been weak since 2007.

    HDFC bank : at least they consistently scale EPS.

    I have met stupid and smart people from all banks – but given the churn in this industry it is hardly indicative of the organization!

    There's more to this than ICICI or ICAI is willing to admit publicly, I'll wager. Given that Arcil is part owned by ICICI they won't make a fuss.

  • Nilesh says:

    >smart people finding a way to increase earning for ICICI. i guess Lehman brothers was also run by smart people. and you already know what they did. the problem with these kind of smart people is that they think that everybody else is fool.

  • Roshan says:

    >I agree Deepak that ICICI is not a stock that a fundamental investor would buy and regret my hasty comments earlier. I am not an big investor and also don't hold any ICICI. You know best about these matters. My only view is that I always go away impressed when I meet the leadership team when compared to their peers. They always have well thought out big initiatives and plans that they execute on well (as compared to other banks).

  • Nagarajan says:

    >no surprise to me. One of my friend took a car loan. After paying few EMIs, ICICI called and gave him back all his EMIs+Advance saying the loan was already paid. And gave a NOC as well.

    This guy took the money and sold off his car. He was not on the hook to pay after getting a NOC.

    6 months after selling his car, he got a call from ICICI claiming it was a mistake. He was honest and paid it. I am sure ICICI has wonderful ways to track their loans 😉

  • Nilesh says:

    >Deepak, question on Tata Capital NCDs. today TCLND2 and TCLND3 are trading at 1169 and 1159. so if i sell them now i can make about 17% profit in 7 months. not bad i would say.

    in one of your earlier post you have calculated yield. how do you do that. r u considering future value as compounded at 12% (interest rate on NCD) for 3 years.

    int pa if sold now and invested in 8% FD = 1170*.08 = 93.60
    int if remain invested = 1000*.12 = 120.00
    so buying them now is still fine. i mean you will make more than FDs

    am i correct in my calculations.

    also any idea when sriram transport and l&t finance will get listed ?

  • aman says:

    >icici is up 40/- bucks or 5.5% the day you published your report.Your analysis is going waywards these days.

    Time to take stock,and may be stop publishing your views publicily.