Actionable insights on equities, fixed-income, macros and personal finance Start 14-Days Free Trial
Actionable investing insights Get Free Trial

Investing in a Bear Market

How does one think about investing in a bear market?

Value suddenly becomes apparent. So apparent that you feel like everything is value. Value is bitch-slapping you across the face right now. It’s oozing out of places you didn’t know were places. Value is everywhere. Bring it on!

Sometimes it’s hindsight – wow, this company was at 5x this price a few months back (think any real estate stock at this point). That’s obviously not right, because the market was overvalued. But they can’t be 80% overvalued no? Uhem. Kindly look at Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae’s one year stock charts. Yes, they can.

Oh ok, wait, this [random] stock is trading at 2 P/E!! How can the price get lower than that? Let me tell you. When your “E” vanishes, that’s how price also goes lower and suddenly the 2 P/E company is a 100 P/E company and the price is still half.

And then you can go in and dip into company balance sheets. The starting of a recession is when companies lie the most. In India, they get away with it – there is no enforcement. In the US, shareholders would sue – and think of it, people still get away with it there – so what they will get away with here is blue murder.

But there is a lot of value out there, surely. You have to now avoid the value pitches that are standard. Let’s try and debunk the value fundas that will come now and how you should look around them.

People will tell you to look at the land bank. What is a land bank? Can you sell the land? SBI has a phenomenal land bank – and very prime too. But it costs way too much to develop it, and the management just isn’t inclined to do it. So there is no land bank. Real estate companies – they can’t fund existing projects, so how will they ever sell those parcels of land? And if all that land came to the market at the same time, wouldn’t prices drop 90%? Don’t ever bother valuing land.

How about the cash on the balance sheet? Some companies trade at cash value – but you have to analyse all other parts of the business too. What if they have huge liabilities that will drain them of the cash? What if the assets they own are so depreciated they will need all the cash to replace them? What if the promoters siphon off the cash by buying dud companies in random places? What if the cash is left unused and there cannot be a takeover because promoters own too much? Cash is a good asset to have, but it has to be valued in conjunction with other parameters.

Some stocks are evergreen. Like Reliance. Or L&T. Or something else. In the 80s, Bombay Burmah was evergreen. In the early 90s, too many companies that were supposed to be evergreen now have green stuff on their graves. Arvind mills was the next big thing and it’s 1/10th that price today (no bonuses, splits etc.). Today there are stocks which people claim are resilient to everything. But they were trading even BELOW these levels just three years ago – Reliance was at 800, L&T was, suitably adjusted, about 200, and HLL was 160. Prices today? 1600, 990 and 250. Even if you take inflation and take these stocks back to those levels, current prices won’t seem like “value”.

Finally, you get people telling you that you should buy when everyone is fearful. That’s huge survivor bias. When a ship full of people crashes, and the only survivor comes out and says “I prayed to god and that saved me” – the religious folks latch on to this and say ‘See? There is a god!”. But what you should ask is: what about all the other people who prayed to god and still drowned?

When rich people tell you buy when everyone is fearful is not telling you what you really should know – how many people who bought at such times lost their money?

Perhaps the best time to buy in a bear market is: at the start of the next bull market. (Meaning: Wait. Let it look like a bull market first. Meaning: when you only turn on CNBC by accident)

Disclosure: Long Nifty. Yeah, I know, I’m a little stupid.

  • DK says:

    >Heh. Nice post (scary, but nice).

    This seems to be a perfect oppurtunity to buy NIFTY. I mean 10% down in a week (tomorrow another 5% drop at the very least I think), there has to be a rebound. right? RIGHT???

    God, I wish I could put money where my mouth is 🙂

  • Anonymous says:

    >Long Term Bear Market bottom for DOW is 3000. For Nifty 1000 Sensex = 2500. After completion of Deleveraging by Hedge Funds who got money from Leveraged Global Banks.

    Follow Mobius if you have no brains and buy now.

    Did your Financial Planner see this coming ?

    Disclosure : I am Short Nifty (4000 OCT Puts bought at 99.5) and My current asset allocation is 90% Debt/Gilt Funds (+8.5% Avg.) and 10% Diversified Equity Funds (which is now -15%)

  • Anonymous says:


    Take a look at the price action on GM today as a result of the S&P ratings action.

    Imagine the storm that would be unleashed by a CDS trigger on GM.
    CDS notional on GM is huge, massive, much more than all the recent triggers we've seen on LEH, FNM, FMC, Fortis, Icelandic banks etc put together

  • Anonymous says:

    >For those interested in hard facts;
    As on 8/10/2008;
    Nifty P/E = 15.10, P/B = 2.93, Dividend Yield = 1.62.

    The worst in recent times was on 9/05/03;
    P/E = 10.86, P/B = 2.02, Div. Yield = 3.17

    If there is World wide panic, investors will disregard fundamentals and only herd mentality will rule.

    I will then go by Dividend Yield then and I think Nifty 1700 would make sense to be safe entry point with little downside (expect for Great Depression II)

    If one were to follow Times of great depression there were several false upmoves before hitting true bear bottom which was 90 loss from peak to trough.

  • Anonymous says:

    >Hi Deepak, I too am currently long on Nifty at an average of 3400 (Nifty futures).. expecting a short term bounce back rally.

    But looking at the SGX Nifty of 3250 today… its sending jitters.

    What do you advice?

  • anirvan says:

    >there is a lehman cds unwind coming up tonight – the final capitulation

  • dexter007 says:

    >I dont think you were stupid in going long. I have been reading your blog for over a year n i think u do a wonderful job. Better than the herd mentality analysts anyways…
    Even i feel markets should give a bounce. Technicals seems to suggest so. Anyways all the best and im in for the long CALL…

  • Anonymous says:

    >Good post and all the more shocking to find you and yr partner turning to bottom calling tomfoolery.
    I know would have been glorious if luck favored.

    Ther are plenty bottom callers as is.

    Let’s keep punting out here, as thought this t.b. a systemic approach. 😉

    Also good comments from anonymous above.

  • Madhavan says:

    >Remembered your post about Mudra Lifestyle. It sounded like good analysis. Just curious. Are you holding on to it?

  • Siddharth says:

    >Deepak have you diagnosed any commere zreeze up scenario in the coming turbulent times?
    Possibly lastign for a month or more whne you go to ATM and find theres no way to get cash.

    Afterall everywhere credit and leverage and if thats frozen for little time is much shock to common man living on credit.
    I dont know but most of the gold bugs are preparing for the SHTF periods.


  • Deepak Shenoy says:

    >madhavan: Still holding on to Mudra. I’ve actually overridden stops on this – and set up a further stop at 22. I’ll reevaluate after this set of results.

    Siddharth: The common man in India doesn’t live on organised credit but I know what you mean. Life is going to be tough…